THE
The
Lake County Value Adjustment Board met in regular session on
CALL TO ORDER
Commr. Stivender called the Value Adjustment Board (VAB) to order.
RECOMMENDATIONS
FROM SPECIAL MAGISTRATE BRUCE DUNCAN EXEMPTION APPEALS HEARD ON
Mr.
Sandy Minkoff,
On a motion by Commr. Hanson, seconded by Ms. Elswick and carried unanimously by a 4-0 vote, the VAB approved to accept the recommendations from Special Magistrate Bruce Duncan, as follows:
RECOMMENDATION |
PET. NO. |
PETITIONER’S NAME |
Denied |
2004-1 |
|
Denied
(written appeal) |
2004-3 |
Joseph
& Anna Klarl |
Denied |
2004-7 |
Jerry
E. Harms |
Denied |
2004-8 |
Perry
& Cheryl Demaio |
Denied |
2004-9L |
Cecelia P. Moore |
RECOMMENDATIONS
FROM SPECIAL MAGISTRATE DAVID TAYLOR VALUATION APPEALS HEARD ON
Mr. Minkoff pointed out that the relief requested for Petition No. 2004-57 – Robert M. Henns/Joan L. Henns Trust/John A. Henns, and Petition 2004-105L, Stan Smith of Lake Hills Inc. of Deltona, had been granted by the Special Magistrate and accepted by the Property Appraiser, for a total impact of about $400,000. There were also two written appeals filed with the Clerk, for Petition 2004-41 – Joseph and Anna Klarl, and for Petitions 2004-107L, 2004-108L, 2004-109L, and 2004-110L – Rob Smith/Riverest, which the members have before them.
Commr. Hanson questioned whether the Chairman was required to open the meeting and ask for public comment, and Mr. Minkoff clarified that no public comment is allowed in this process. Mr. Minkoff also pointed out that Mr. Taylor had indicated in his report that Mr. Klarl’s property had been listed at $750,000.
On a motion by Commr. Hanson, seconded by Ms. Elswick and carried unanimously by a 4-0 vote, the VAB approved to accept the recommendations from Special Magistrate David Taylor, as follows:
RECOMMENDATION |
PET. NO. |
PETITIONER'S NAME |
|
|
|
Denied |
2004-10 |
Glen D. Brecheen |
Denied |
2004-12 |
Lake Square Mall |
Denied |
2004-28 |
Rinker Materials |
Denied |
2004-29 |
Rinker Materials/Florida
Crushed Stone |
Denied |
2004-30 |
Rinker Materials/Florida
Crushed Stone |
Denied |
2004-31 |
Rinker Materials |
Denied |
2004-32 |
Rinker Materials |
Denied |
2004-38 |
Lee Lemke |
Denied |
2004-40 |
Richard & Miriam
Holliday |
Denied (written appeal) |
2004-41 |
Joseph & Anna Klarl |
Denied |
2004-46 |
Spanish
Village MHP |
Denied |
2004-51 |
AT&T |
Denied |
2004-52 |
AT&T |
Denied |
2004-53 |
AT&T |
Denied |
2004-54 |
BCC Equip Leasing |
Granted |
2004-57 |
Robert M. Henns/Joan L.
Henns Trust/John A. Henns |
Denied |
2004-60 |
Brendan R. McGee, Golf
Trust of America/Black Bear Golf Club |
Denied |
2004-64 |
Kristen Bartch |
Denied |
2004-65 |
Kristen Bartch |
Denied |
2004-66 |
Kristen Bartch |
Denied |
2004-67 |
Kristen Bartch |
Denied |
2004-69 |
Don R. Hartman |
Denied |
2004-70 |
The |
Denied |
2004-77 |
Crossings at Leesburg
(Apts.) |
Denied |
2004-78 |
Crossings at Leesburg
(Apts.) |
Denied |
2004-79 |
Crossings at Leesburg
(Apts.) |
Denied |
2004-84 |
|
Denied |
2004-93 |
Olive Garden #1171 |
Denied |
2004-94 |
Red Lobster #480 |
Granted |
2004-105L |
Stan Smith of Lake Hills
Inc. Of Deltona |
Denied (written appeal) |
2004-107L |
Rob Smith/Riverest |
Denied (written appeal) |
2004-108L |
Rob Smith/Riverest |
Denied (written appeal) |
2004-109L |
Rob Smith/Riverest |
Denied (written appeal) |
2004-110L |
Rob Smith/Riverest |
Denied |
2004-111L |
Charles M. Rehler |
DISCUSSION
OF PREVIOUS ITEM
Under
discussion of the previous items relating to the two petitions filed by Joseph
and Anna Klarl, Commr. Hanson informed the VAB that their property is actually
listed with her real estate company, and she needs to go back and rescind her
vote on Petitions 2004-3, and 2004-41.
On a motion by Commr. Hill, seconded by Ms. Elswick and carried by a 3-0 vote, the VAB approved to rehear Petition 2004-3 and Petition 2004-41, for Joseph and Anna Klarl.
Commr.
Hanson declared a conflict of interest and did not vote on the motion.
On
a motion by Commr. Hill, seconded by Ms. Elswick and carried by a 3-0 vote, the
VAB approved the recommendations from the special magistrates, as noted, to
deny the relief requested in Petitions 2004-3 and 2004-41, Joseph and Anna
Klarl.
Commr.
Hanson declared a conflict of interest and did not vote on the motion, due to
the subject property being listed with her real estate company.
MINUTES
On
a motion by Ms. Elswick, seconded by Commr. Hill and carried unanimously by a
4-0 vote, the VAB approved the VAB Minutes of
REVENUE
AND EXPENSE SUMMARY
It
was noted that the total amount of revenue received from filing fees was
$1,655.00, which would offset the special magistrate total contract billings, in
the amount of $5,882.00.
On
a motion by Commr. Hill, seconded by Commr. Hanson and carried unanimously by a
4-0 vote, the VAB approved to bill, pursuant to Chapter 194.015, Florida
Statues, the following: the Lake County
School Board for two-fifths of the net expenses, in the amount of $1,690.80;
and the Board of County Commissioners for three-fifths of the net expenses, in the
amount of $2,536.20.
CERTIFICATES
OF VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD
On
a motion by Commr. Hanson, seconded by Ms. Elswick and carried unanimously by a
4-0 vote, the VAB approved the Certificates of Value Adjustment Board, as
follows: Real Property – Pursuant to
Section 193.122, Florida Statutes – the amount of $10,568,056,026; and Tangible
Personal Property – Pursuant to Section 193.122, Florida Statutes – the amount
of $1,154,687,370.
RECESS
Mr. Minkoff clarified that the VAB
does not actually adjourn because it is possible that another item could come
up for review.
At
______________________________
DEBBIE STIVENDER, CHAIRMAN
ATTEST:
__________________________
JAMES C. WATKINS, CLERK